Brand page · General Office Supplies
The Paper Mill Store: 90.5k visits a month, 9 active Meta ads.
The Paper Mill Store — The Paper Mill Store is an online retailer that sells paper, card stock, envelopes and other paper products from various mills. They offer business cards, letterhead, stationery, and provide free shipping with rewards and discounts. In September 2026 thepapermillstore.com drew an estimated 90.5k visits, up 12% on the month before. It ranks #47 of 3,465 General Office Supplies brands and holds a 4.6 Trustpilot rating over 33 reviews.
Updated Traffic Sept 2026Meta ads 13 Oct 2026Google ads 21 Oct 2026Trustpilot Oct 2026
About the store
The Paper Mill Store is an online retailer that sells paper, card stock, envelopes and other paper products from various mills. They offer business cards, letterhead, stationery, and provide free shipping with rewards and discounts.
01 · Traffic
How much traffic The Paper Mill Store gets.
The traffic card of the Gravity brand page: the latest month and its two trends. The monthly curve, 24 months of history, the audience by country, the traffic sources and the category comparison are for members, free to start.
The Paper Mill Store drew an estimated 90.5k visits in September 2026, up 12% on the month before and up 8% over three months.
- Worldwide#102,011of 4.5m sites · Top 5%
- In United States#33,281of 1.2m sites · Top 5%
- General Office Supplies, worldwide#246of 19,660 brands · Top 5%
- General Office Supplies, United States#47of 3,465 brands · Top 5%
90.5k
estimated visits in September
1 mo ▲ +12.2%4 mo ▲ +7.6%
The monthly curve, 24 months of history and the category comparison.
Create your free account02 · Reviews
What customers say about The Paper Mill Store.
The review cards of the Gravity brand page: the Trustpilot page, with its star distribution and the brand's tiers against the index, and the Google reviews. The TrustScore history and the review velocity against the category are for signed-in members.
The Paper Mill Store holds 4.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot over 33 reviews, 32 of them in the last twelve months: 88% of customers give five stars and 0% one star. That volume places The Paper Mill Store in the top 50% of the 270,321 Trustpilot pages in the Gravity index, and its rating quality in the top 30%.
Prints and Signs Store Stationery Store Digital Printing Service Office Supply Store
Data not available
Review velocity, TrustScore history and the category comparison are on the Gravity brand page.
03 · Products
What The Paper Mill Store sells, ranked by sales.
The top three products in the catalogue, in the store's own best-seller order, with price and stock. The full catalogue, the rankings over time and the ads that lead to each product are for signed-in members.
Gravity by Benchr has not read The Paper Mill Store's catalogue yet.
Data not available
Data not available
Share of the catalogue by product family.
The dominant category places The Paper Mill Store in its comparison group.
- Average rating
- Data not available
- Rated products
- Data not available
- In stock
- Data not available
- Upper price quartile
- Data not available
- Currency
- Data not available
04 · Ads
What The Paper Mill Store is advertising right now.
Meta and Google ads, as the Gravity brand page shows them; the blurred ones are placeholders. Every creative, how long it ran, its EU reach and the estimated monthly spend band are for signed-in members.
The Paper Mill Store runs Meta ads on Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, Audience Network, Threads, and has advertised on Google since October 2021 (image, text, video).
Paper, Card Stock, Envelopes & MoreThe Paper Mill Store3 Oct 2026image
Card Stock & Cover PaperThe Paper Mill Store16 Jul 2026image
CLASSIC Stipple Solar White Card Stock - 18 x 12 in 100 lb Cover Stipple Digital 125 per PackageThe Paper Mill Store15 Jul 2026image- +View all Meta adsReach per ad, how long each creative ran, and the estimated monthly spend band. Free account.Sign in to Gravity
Text ad21 Oct 2026THE PAPER MILL STORE INCverified
Text ad21 Oct 2026THE PAPER MILL STORE INCverified
Text ad21 Oct 2026THE PAPER MILL STORE INCverified
- +View all Google adsFormats, first and last seen, and the keywords the brand bids on. Free account.Sign in to Gravity
05 · Influencers
Who talks about The Paper Mill Store.
The creators who tag @papermillstore on Instagram, found by Gravity by Benchr in their posts. One is shown here; the full list, the audiences and the contact details are for signed-in members.
Gravity has not found creators tagging this brand on Instagram yet.
Gravity has not found creators tagging this brand on Instagram yet.
06 · Competitors according to Gravity
Who The Paper Mill Store competes with, by the numbers.
Gravity picks competitors from the index itself: same category, same market, similar size. The closest are named here; their figures, the full list and the side-by-side comparison are for subscribers.
Gravity by Benchr finds competitors for The Paper Mill Store among General Office Supplies brands. The closest is Rzeczownik, then ARIMANY, schiff.ch, julie-flamingo.com, skrepka24.ru, thermalpaperdirect.com.
| Brand | Similarity | Gravity score | Est. traffic | Trustpilot | Meta ads | Products | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Rzeczownikrzeczownik.com | |||||||
| ARIMANYarimany.com | |||||||
| schiff.chschiff.ch | |||||||
| julie-flamingo.comjulie-flamingo.com | |||||||
| skrepka24.ruskrepka24.ru | |||||||
| thermalpaperdirect.comthermalpaperdirect.com |
07 · Company
The company behind The Paper Mill Store.
Legal entity, funding and distribution, as the Company tab of the Gravity brand page shows them. Where Gravity has nothing on file, the line says so rather than disappearing.
The Paper Mill Store is an e-commerce brand, on a domain registered in May 2004.
- Legal name
- Data not available
- Registration no.
- Data not available
- VAT
- Data not available
- Legal form
- Data not available
- Entity country
- Data not available
- Founded
- Data not available
- Domain registered
- 3 May 2004
- Share capital
- Data not available
- Status
- Data not available
- President
- Data not available
- Activity code
- Data not available
- Employees
- Data not available
- Funding stage
- Data not available
- Total raised
- Data not available
- Investors
- Data not available
- VC-backed
- Data not available
- Own store
- thepapermillstore.com · Magento
- Catalogue
- Data not available
- Retailers
- None recorded
- Open jobs
- None recorded
08 · What people ask about The Paper Mill Store
What people ask Google about The Paper Mill Store.
10 answers built from the data on this page, each one sourced to Gravity by Benchr, which say so when we don't know.
Is The Paper Mill Store legit?
According to Gravity by Benchr, The Paper Mill Store is a brand: its website has existed since May 2004, its Trustpilot profile is claimed by the brand, it sells on a Magento store, it has 801 Instagram followers. Those are the marks of an established brand, not a pop-up shop. Source: Gravity by Benchr brand index, September 2026.
The Paper Mill Store reviews: is it worth it?
Customers rate The Paper Mill Store 4.6 out of 5 on Trustpilot over 33 reviews, 32 of them in the last twelve months: 88% give five stars, 0% one star. Gravity by Benchr places that review volume in the top 50% of the 270,321 Trustpilot pages in its index. Source: Gravity by Benchr Trustpilot reading, October 2026.
What is The Paper Mill Store?
The Paper Mill Store is an online retailer that sells paper, card stock, envelopes and other paper products from various mills. They offer business cards, letterhead, stationery, and provide free shipping with rewards and discounts. Gravity by Benchr classifies it under General Office Supplies. Source: Gravity by Benchr product classification.
The Paper Mill Store promo code
Gravity by Benchr does not collect discount codes. What Gravity observes: The Paper Mill Store advertises on Facebook and Instagram and on Google, where its offers often run. Check thepapermillstore.com for current promotions. Source: Gravity by Benchr ad records, October 2026.
Where to buy The Paper Mill Store?
The Paper Mill Store sells on its own website, thepapermillstore.com, a Magento store. Gravity by Benchr lists no retailer or marketplace for the brand. Source: Gravity by Benchr retailer data.
Who is behind The Paper Mill Store?
Gravity by Benchr records a company, whose domain was registered in 2004. Gravity publishes no personal data about founders. Source: Gravity by Benchr company records.
Is The Paper Mill Store doing well?
Yes. Gravity by Benchr estimates about 90,500 visits to thepapermillstore.com in September 2026, up 12% in a month and up 8% over three months. The Paper Mill Store ranks #47 of 3,465 General Office Supplies brands in the Gravity index. Source: Gravity by Benchr estimated traffic, September 2026.
Which platform and tools does The Paper Mill Store use?
Gravity by Benchr identifies thepapermillstore.com as a Magento store. The brand has claimed its Trustpilot profile. It advertises through Meta and on Google since October 2021. Source: Gravity by Benchr platform and advertising records.
What is The Paper Mill Store's ad budget?
Gravity by Benchr does not publish a spend figure for The Paper Mill Store on this page. What Gravity observes: an active Meta advertiser, on Facebook, Instagram, Messenger, Audience Network, Threads. The estimated monthly spend band, derived from the EU reach of each ad, is on the Gravity brand page. Source: Gravity by Benchr Meta Ad Library records, October 2026.
Who are the biggest General Office Supplies brands?
Among General Office Supplies brands in the Gravity by Benchr index, The Paper Mill Store ranks #47 of 3,465 by estimated traffic. Its closest competitors on the same market are Rzeczownik, ARIMANY, schiff.ch, julie-flamingo.com and skrepka24.ru. Source: Gravity by Benchr competitor analysis, same category, same market, similar size.
Gravity by Benchr indexes more than 4 million e-commerce brands across 150 countries. Figures on this page are estimates, updated monthly; the Gravity score is recomputed nightly. Not affiliated with The Paper Mill Store.